Sunlit covered porch of a single-story home with gray wood siding, stone column bases, a wood entry door and a dry planted front garden.

Prescott Sellers Kept Listing This Fall After Buyers Stepped Back

"Prescott Valley, by contrast, recorded stronger sales and pricing despite fewer new listings."

That sentence comes from the Prescott Area Association of REALTORS® September 2026 market statistics release. The comparison it makes is with Prescott, where the same release reports that total sales fell 26.9% year over year in September 2026, from 175 closings to 128.

The two cities slowed for opposite reasons. In Prescott, buyers left and sellers stayed. In Prescott Valley, sellers left and buyers stayed. If you're deciding where to make an offer this winter, that matters more than either city's median price.

Four months of the same pattern

One month of data can mislead, so here is the summer and early fall for both cities. These figures come from PAAR's monthly reports as published by Signals AZ for June through September 2026.

2026 Prescott sales Prescott new listings Prescott active inventory Prescott median days on market Prescott Valley sales Prescott Valley new listings Prescott Valley active inventory Prescott Valley median days on market
June 156 222 678 33 96 143 364 33
July 157 211 698 44 95 124 371 33
August 131 195 693 49 93 109 341 36
September 128 166 672 51 100 98 317 39

Prescott's active inventory stayed between 672 and 698 homes from June through September 2026. Its sales fell by about 28 a month over the same period, and median days on market rose every month, from 33 to 51. In Prescott Valley, sales held between 93 and 100 a month while the number of homes for sale fell from 371 in July to 317 in September.

Prescott's unsold homes stayed listed and waited longer, which is what happens when buyers are scarce. Prescott Valley's supply shrank, which is what happens when sellers are scarce.

Prescott Valley's sellers listed fewer homes than buyers bought

In September 2026, Prescott Valley had 98 new listings and 100 closed sales. Fewer homes came on the market than sold that month. PAAR's release puts that in year-over-year terms. New listings fell 20.3%, from 123 in September 2025 to 98. Sales rose 5.3%, from 95 to 100. The median sold price rose 13.6%, from $435,000 to $494,000, and median days on market fell from 49 to 39.

A 13.6% jump in the median looks like heavy demand. The sales count suggests something more modest. Buyer activity rose by five closings. The supply side changed far more, with 25 fewer new listings than a year earlier. When the number of buyers holds steady and the number of homes for sale shrinks, competing buyers push prices up. Prescott Valley's months of inventory was 3.5 in September 2026, the tightest of the two cities.

Prescott's sellers kept coming while buyers thinned out

In Prescott, PAAR reports that new listings fell only 4.6% year over year in September 2026, from 174 to 166, while sales fell 26.9%. The median sold price fell 2.8%, from $607,000 to $589,950. Prescott sellers listed at nearly last year's pace, and roughly one in four of last September's buyers didn't show up.

Prescott's year-over-year days-on-market number looks calm, with the median at 51 days in September 2026 versus 52 a year earlier. The month-by-month figures show the change. In June 2026, a Prescott home went under contract in a median of 33 days, the same as in Prescott Valley. By September, Prescott was at 51 days and Prescott Valley at 39. The two cities started the summer at the same pace and ended it 12 days apart.

Prescott's months of inventory was 5.2 in September 2026, compared with 3.5 in Prescott Valley. A buyer in Prescott has about half again as much supply to choose from relative to the pace of sales.

Mortgage rates don't explain the split

The obvious explanation is rates. Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed average at 7.18% as of November 5, 2026, down from 7.24% the week before, compared with 6.22% a year earlier. A full point of extra interest should hit the more expensive market harder, so it seems to explain why Prescott slowed.

The payment math points the other way. The figures below are rough principal-and-interest estimates on a 30-year loan with 20% down at each city's September median. They leave out taxes, insurance and HOA dues, so they illustrate the trend and aren't a quote for any buyer.

  1. Prescott, September 2025. A $607,000 median at 6.22% works out to about $2,980 a month.
  2. Prescott, September 2026. A $589,950 median at 7.18% works out to about $3,200 a month, roughly $220 more.
  3. Prescott Valley, September 2025. A $435,000 median at 6.22% works out to about $2,140 a month.
  4. Prescott Valley, September 2026. A $494,000 median at 7.18% works out to about $2,680 a month, roughly $540 more.

Prescott Valley's typical payment rose more than twice as much as Prescott's, and its sales went up. Prescott's rose less, and its sales fell by a quarter. Rates put the same pressure on both cities, so the gap has to come from what sellers did. Prescott Valley owners largely held off on listing. Prescott owners kept listing as buyers thinned out.

Prescott's median price swings too much to track

In the four months above, Prescott's median sold price was $632,500 in June, $599,900 in July, $655,000 in August and $589,950 in September 2026. Values didn't move $55,000 in a month and then fall back $65,000. With 128 to 157 sales a month across very different housing stock, the median depends on which homes happened to close that month.

Days on market and active inventory hold up better, and in Prescott both point the same way. PAAR's all-area September 2026 report adds a related figure. Across the full association region, median price per square foot was $282, down 2.1% from a year earlier, while showings per listing rose 10.7% to 3.1. Those numbers cover all four quad-city communities rather than Prescott alone. They match what Prescott's own data shows: buyers are visiting more homes before choosing one.

What this means when you make an offer

For a buyer comparing the two cities this winter, the difference comes down to timing and leverage.

  • In Prescott, the steady 670-plus active listings and a median of 51 days on market in September 2026 mean many sellers have had their homes listed through at least one month without a contract. A listing at that stage gives a buyer room to discuss price, repair requests or closing timelines.
  • In Prescott Valley, a September in which new listings fell short of sales means a well-priced home faces competition from buyers who have been waiting for inventory. The 39-day median is still well above a frenzy, but it fell 10 days from a year earlier.
  • If you're weighing both cities, the price gap is only part of the comparison. In September 2026, Prescott Valley's median was about $96,000 below Prescott's. A buyer in Prescott, though, is negotiating in a market with more supply and longer listing times.

FAQ

Is Prescott becoming a buyer's market?

The trend favors buyers. In September 2026, Prescott sales fell 26.9% from a year earlier while new listings fell only 4.6%, and median days on market rose every month from June through September.

Will Prescott Valley prices keep rising?

The 13.6% jump in September 2026 came from fewer new listings, not a surge in buyers. If more owners list this winter, that pressure would ease. The supply numbers are the ones to watch.

Which figures matter most in the next monthly report?

New listings compared with sales in each city. In September 2026, Prescott had 1.3 new listings for every sale, and Prescott Valley had fewer than one.

The payment figures above are general estimates, not financial advice. A lender can tell you what your own rate, down payment and costs would look like. Whether you're buying in the city with more supply or selling in the one with less, the Paula Stears Thomas PST: Premier Sales Team can show you where your home or your target street falls in this month's numbers. Get your free home valuation to see what the Prescott and Prescott Valley data means for your home.

Work With Paula

Whether you're buying your first home, upgrading to fit your growing family, or searching for the perfect investment, Paula brings warmth, dedication, and deep local insight to every step of the journey. With a sharp eye for detail and a passion for helping people find “the one,” Paula makes the process feel effortless—and even enjoyable. Let her guide you with honesty, care, and a commitment to achieving your real estate goals.

Follow Me on Instagram